Single-axle tractor diesel or gasoline, which is better?
Our people have always loved to do earthworks on their dacha plot or vegetable garden. Previously, they used only hand tools for this purpose, which took a lot of effort and time. If you had to work a large enough piece of land, you had to rent a tractor, but with the current price of fuel and how much it consumes a large tractor, it is extremely unprofitable to do so.
Relatively recently, such type of garden equipment as a single-axle tractor has appeared on the market. It has an engine, steering system, steering wheel and two wheels. Various attachments or a trailer can be connected to it. In this case, the tiller can not only plow the land, but also use it as a complete vehicle for transporting goods.
Depending on the type of engine, power tillers are differentiated:
Each of these types has its own features, which distinguish them from their competitor. Single axle tractor. diesel or gasoline what is better? To answer this question, we need to consider each type separately.
Let’s start with the cheaper gasoline power tillers. As already written in the previous sentence, they have a more affordable price. The purchasing power of the population in rural areas leaves much to be desired. Therefore, people are more interested in the cheaper equipment. They have small dimensions, weight and are less quiet in operation. They are convenient to use in small areas. Repair of power tillers with gasoline engine is easier and cheaper. They start well in all kinds of weather and temperatures.
Features of a diesel power tiller
Diesel motoblocs are the best option of machinery for processing large areas of crops. The equipment can have a capacity of over 12 liters. с., which equals the parameters of compact minitractors. With a mass of more than a hundred kilograms, a single-axle tractor on a diesel is heavy enough, able to cope with agricultural work of any complexity.
The diesel engine has its own advantages:
- Minimum fuel consumption regardless of the power of the unit;
- High torque and traction gain;
- Long service life and low operating costs (repairs are rarely required);
- Robustness at work because of the unit’s high weight.
The motorcycle is equipped with a multi-stage transmission, which allows to function in different modes. The machine is not very maneuverable, but it is effective in the field. Diesel single axle tractor is quite expensive, the quality of fuel used must be high. It is necessary to maintain the Chinese/Russian unit, adhering to strict rules.
Advantages of diesel power tillers
But diesel power tillers also have a number of serious advantages over gasoline ones:
- Economy;
- Greater tractive power;
- Can work for a long time without stopping;
- convenient in operation and maintenance.
Despite the fact that the diesel single-axle tractor is more expensive, during its operation this disadvantage is completely leveled. During operation, diesel engines save 2 to 5 liters of fuel per 100 kilometers than their gasoline counterparts. If we consider that diesel fuel itself costs 4-6% cheaper than the most demanded gasoline A-92 gasoline for gasoline tractors, we get significant savings. For most operations in tillage: plowing, cultivation, hilling. a diesel single-axle tractor is more practical. It has a much higher value of tractive effort than the gasoline engine, so it can operate for a long time at low speed without resting. For those who are not familiar with machinery, the diesel engine is preferable if only by the fact that it does not have a carburetor, magneto and spark plugs which require regular cleaning and adjustment.
The heavier weight of the diesel engine tractor in comparison with the gasoline one can be considered both as a disadvantage and an advantage. A disadvantage because it puts more strain on the worker’s hands. But at the expense of greater weight traction with the ground is improved, and it gives good results in the development of virgin lands and other heavy earthworks that lighter gasoline tractors simply can not do.
Advantages of diesel power tillers
But diesel power tillers also have a number of serious advantages over gasoline ones:
- Efficiency;
- Greater tractive effort;
- Can work for a long time without stopping;
- convenient in operation and service.
In spite of the fact that a diesel single-axle tractor costs more, during its operation this drawback is completely leveled. During operation per 100 km run, diesel engines save from 2 to 5 liters of fuel than their gasoline counterparts. If we take into account that the diesel fuel itself costs 4-6% cheaper than the most demanded gasoline A-92 gasoline for gasoline power tillers, then the economy is substantial. For the majority of tillage operations: plowing, cultivation, hilling. a diesel single-axle tractor is more practical. It has much more pulling power than a gasoline tractor, so it can work long hours at low speeds without resting. For those who are familiar with the technique on “you”, the diesel engine is preferable at least by the fact that it has no carburetor, magneto and spark plugs that require regular cleaning and adjustment.
The greater weight of a diesel engine tractor in comparison with a gasoline one can be viewed as a disadvantage as well as an advantage. Disadvantage. because it puts more strain on the worker’s hands. But at the expense of more weight traction with the ground is improved, and it gives a good result for the development of virgin lands and other heavy earthworks, which more easily gasoline blocks simply can not do.
Specifics of a gasoline-engine motorblower
Gasoline single-axle tractor. popular type of equipment with up to 9 liters capacity. с. The unit is often used for plowing, cultivation, loosening and ditching. The single-axle gasoline-powered tractor is comparatively small, economical and easy to use in small areas.
Pros of using this equipment:
- Practicality and versatility. The kit can include a variety of attachments for many tasks;
- High fuel economy. Low fuel consumption; Quite high power and efficiency;
- Small size. According to the owners’ feedback, it is convenient to use the machine in small areas;
- Low noise level;
- Ability to work regardless of weather conditions.
Most power tillers have a transmission with several gears. It makes it possible to work on different soils regardless of their density and composition. It is possible to transport trailers and solve many municipal problems with a gasoline motor-block.
Specifics of a gasoline single-axle tractor
Gasoline single-axle tractor. a popular form of equipment with up to 9 liters of power. с. The unit is often used for plowing, cultivating, loosening and tilling. The single-axle gasoline-powered tractor is relatively small, economical and convenient to use on small plots.
The pros of using this technique:
- Practicality and versatility. Various attachments can be included for solving many problems;
- High economy. Low fuel consumption, productivity and efficiency are high enough;
- Small size. According to feedback from owners, it is convenient to use the technique in small areas;
- Low noise level;
- Ability to work regardless of weather conditions.
Most power tillers have a transmission with several gears. It makes it possible to work on different soils regardless of their density and composition. You can use a gasoline-powered tiller to haul trailers and perform numerous municipal tasks.
Which engine should you choose??
In order to answer which engine is the best for your power tiller. diesel or gasoline, it is first important to determine how much time per year you plan to use it and what kind of work you want to do. Because a properly selected good single-axle tractor can replace a mini-tractor in many ways. It can plow, carry loads, clear snow and perform many other tasks.
In the domestic market a large selection of both gasoline and diesel powerblocks. Among gasoline-powered models, popular models are:
- Centaur MB 2070B/M2;
- Centaur MB 2070B-3;
- Centaur MB 2091B;
- Centaur MB 40-1;
- Zirka GT90G03;
- Zirka GT70G01;
- Forte MK-2K-7.0;
- Forte NSD1G-105G.
Among the diesel in popularity hold the primacy:
- Zubr JRO 12E;
- Zubr NT.105;
- Centaur MB 1080 D;
- Centaur MB 1010;
- Centaur 2075;
- Centaur 2091D;
- Aurora 135 E;
- Zirka GT76D02E;
- Zirka GT90D04;
- Bulat VT1210E;
- Forte HSD1G-81;
- Forte HSD1G-135;
- Weima 1100BE.
This is not a complete list of models of both gasoline and diesel power tillers. But even superficially analyzing these lists, it is easy to see that they contain different models of the same brands, and sometimes the only difference between two models of the same brand is just the difference in the power plant.
If you want to make the right choice, there’s one simple rule. If a single-axle tractor is purchased for a small area, such as cottages with 10-30 acres of soft land on which, in addition, grows a dozen or so fruit trees, then the lightweight and maneuverable single-axle gasoline tractor is preferable. It is not only easier to turn a small area, get around tree trunks and dodge branches during work, but thanks to its small size it is never a problem to store the petrol tiller in the country house, where there is often no outbuildings.
If the machinery is purchased in order to cultivate 50-70 hectares of land, not to mention the cases when the matter concerns areas over a hectare or a heavy clay soil, and on top of that it is planned that it will serve as a means of transportation of grown crops from the field to home, then it is better to use a diesel single-axle tractor.
The dispute about what is better: diesel or gasoline. is destined to long life, because each of the two options has numerous proponents and opponents. But, paying (and rightly so) close attention to the choice of a power tiller, we should not forget that the efficiency of its work depends not only on the type, class and brand. Proper storage and operation of the machine is also of great importance. But this is another topic for conversation.
Advantages of gasoline single axle tractors
The main advantage of the gasoline motor over the diesel engine is that it is much easier and, what is important, cheaper to maintain and repair. But this is not all the advantages of gasoline motor blocks over diesel ones. In addition to repair and maintenance, gasoline single axle tractors have a number of other serious advantages:
- Less dependence on weather conditions;
- Relatively low price;
- Lightness;
- Maneuverability;
- When working they make less noise;
- Practically no vibration of the steering wheel.
Because of its design advantages, gasoline engines don’t need an electric starter. Due to its compression, a gasoline engine is much easier to start in freezing temperatures than a diesel engine. In addition, research has shown that the noise level of the gasoline engine is much lower (up to 30 decibels) than that of the diesel engine.
Due to the fact that the gasoline single-axle tractor vibrates less, during operation, its steering wheel is much easier to hold than the diesel steering wheel, so your hands are much less tired.
Advantages of diesel single-axle tractors
But the diesel engine blocks have a number of significant advantages over gasoline engines:
- Economy;
- Greater pulling power;
- Can run for long periods of time without stopping;
- convenient in operation and service.
In spite of the fact that a diesel single-axle tractor costs more, during its operation this drawback is completely leveled. During the work per 100 km of run the diesel engines save from 2 to 5 liters of fuel than their gasoline counterparts. If we take into account that diesel fuel itself costs 4-6% cheaper than the most demanded gasoline A-92 gasoline for gasoline power tillers, the economy is significant.
A diesel single-axle tractor is more practical for most tillage operations: plowing, cultivation, hilling. It has a much higher pulling force rating than a gasoline-powered one, so it can run for long periods of time at low speeds without resting. For those who are with the technique on “you”, the diesel engine is preferable at least by the fact that it does not have a carburetor, magneto and candles, requiring regular cleaning and adjustment.
The heavier weight of a diesel engine tractor compared to a gasoline one can be considered both as a drawback and an advantage. The disadvantage is that since it is a great burden on the hands of the worker. But due to the greater weight, the traction with the ground improves, and this gives a good result in the development of virgin lands and other heavy earthworks, which the lighter petrol motoblocs simply can not do.
Peculiarities of the diesel motor block
Diesel power tillers. the best option of equipment for the processing of large sown areas. The equipment can have a capacity of more than 12 liters. с., which is equal to the parameters of compact minitractors. With a mass of more than a hundred kilograms, a single-axle tractor on a diesel is heavy enough, able to cope with agricultural work of any complexity.
The diesel engine has its own advantages:
- Minimum fuel consumption regardless of the unit power;
- High torque and pulling power;
- Long service life and low operating costs (repairs are rarely required)
- Sturdy operation because of the machine’s high weight.
It is equipped with a multi-stage transmission, which allows to operate in different modes. Not very maneuverable, but efficient in the field.
A diesel single axle tractor is quite expensive, the quality of fuel used must be high. The Chinese/Russian machine should be serviced, following strict rules.
Specifics of a gasoline single-axle tractor
Gasoline single-axle tractor. demanded type of equipment with up to 9 liters of power. с. The machine is often used for plowing, cultivating, loosening, and ditching the ground. Gasoline single axle tractor is relatively small, economical and easy to use on small plots.
The advantages of using this technique:
- Practicality and universality. A variety of attachments can be included for many tasks;
- High fuel economy. With low fuel consumption, productivity and efficiency are high enough;
- Small size. According to the reviews of owners, it is convenient to use the technique on small territories;
- Low noise level;
- Ability to work regardless of weather conditions.
Most power tillers have transmission with several gears. This makes it possible to work on different soils, regardless of their density and composition. Gasoline-powered tiller can be used for transporting trailers and solving numerous municipal problems.
Peculiarities of a diesel engine block
With the help of diesel power tillers it is possible to cultivate a considerable area under crops. Power capacity of such machines can be from 12 hp. с., that can be compared to compact minitractors. With a mass of more than 100 kg, the motor is heavy enough, so it will cope with tasks of any complexity.
What advantages a diesel single-axle tractor can boast?
- Low consumption of diesel. Consumption depends on the power of the motor, but even at 12 liters. с. The technique is characterized by cost-effectiveness;
- Easy maintenance and repair. The unit has no candles, carburetor and magneto, these are the ones that most often break down;
- high weight. The unit is perfectly meshed with the soil without the need to buy special weights;
- Different types of coolers. Reduced temperature by water or air (gasoline motor blocks without water cooling).
The diesel engine has a large stock of resources, so all tasks are performed quickly and at a decent level.
What disadvantages do diesel power tillers have??
- High price. The cost of equipment quickly pay off because of the relatively low price for fuel;
- the machine has to be started at maximum power. It’s not always perceived negatively, but idling can provoke malfunctions.
Among the most popular brands, it is worth highlighting the following:
These models have a specialized anti-corrosion coating on the frame, the gearbox is made of cast iron. Such characteristics allow to protect the unit from sharp changes of load.
the single-axle tractor is equipped with a multi-stage transmission, which allows it to work in different modes. The machine can not boast of maneuverability, but it is very effective in carrying out various works in the field.
Diesel single-axle tractor will cost the future owner not cheap, you need to fill only high-quality fuel. Such a Chinese/Russian machine must be maintained in accordance with all operating rules.
Specifics of a gasoline single-axle tractor
Gasoline-powered machines are still in high demand. The power of such motoblocks up to 9 liters. с. With the help of this machine the soil is plowed, cultivated, loosened and dug.
The power tillers are small, economical and easy to use on small plots of land.
Advantages of the petrol-engine tractors?
- Low price. Among the huge modern variety of equipment, you can find the most suitable unit for functionality and cost;
- Affordable maintenance. Specialists carry out all necessary repairs quickly and qualitatively. Individual faults can be repaired by yourself;
- Low noise level. Diesel single axle tractor makes much more noise;
- A slight vibration of the steering wheel. Management of technology does not require special skills, so the gasoline-powered models are best suited for novice operators;
- Easy start. The single-axle tractor starts up regardless of the weather and without having to heat up the fuel.
All these advantages are confirmed by numerous reviews of the owners.
Gasoline motor blocks have the following disadvantages:
- Low power level. With these models of power tillers one can work on the land within 25 hectares. The technique can not cope with heavy loads;
- Single air-cooling system. You cannot use a single-axle tractor for a long time without breaks. Excessive loads can cause the unit to break down.
Among the whole wide range of gasoline models, it is worth highlighting the following:
With such a variety, you can pick up a single-axle tractor on gasoline, which will meet all the needs and wishes of the owner.
Specifics of gasoline power tillers
Most often these units are purchased for small plots of land. Their basic advantages are affordable price and excellent performance.
over, in a gasoline engine for a power tiller, the fuel is ignited by a spark produced by means of spark plugs. Absolutely all models are not heavy and have excellent maneuverability, so it is quite easy and pleasant to control them.
The gasoline engine can be started very quickly, regardless of weather conditions. That is, even in winter there is no need to worry about the fact that the fuel will thicken in the cold and buy additional devices for heating.
It is worth noting that in the event of problems, it will be relatively inexpensive to repair the single-axle gasoline tractor. Other features include a low noise level, virtually imperceptible vibration of the steering wheel during operation and excellent compression.
Advantages of gasoline power tillers
- Low cost of the power tiller. The modern variety of devices on the market will allow you to choose the most suitable option, both from a functional and financial point of view;
- Inexpensive maintenance. Specialists are always ready to do all the necessary work, and to carry out some of them at home is also not difficult;
- Low noise level. “Sounds” the device a few dozen decibels lower than a diesel single-axle tractor;
- The ease of starting a gasoline engine. It can be done in all weather conditions, without the need to warm up the fuel;
- Little vibration of the steering wheel. If a person does not have special experience in operating power tillers, the gasoline version is the ideal start for him to get acquainted with these multifunctional devices.
As you can see, the considered type of power tiller also has a lot of quite curious and proven in practice advantages.
Disadvantages of gasoline power tillers
- Low power. Gasoline units are suitable only for working on plots of up to 20-30 acres. They will not withstand heavy loads;
- Only air cooling. This means that it is not recommended to exploit the “helper” all day, because such a load can cause a breakdown.
Since the variety of gasoline options is impressive, it’s imperative to learn about a few of the most common models:
Each option has its own characteristics, so pick up the unit to your liking and finances will not be difficult.
Selection tips
When choosing a power tiller you should consider the following criteria:
The area of the plot to be cultivated.2. Soil type (availability of virgin land, heavy or light soil).3. Types of work that will be performed by a single axle tractor.4. The additional equipment required, the PTO, the model’s features. 5. Cultivation width and depth.6. Value for money, economy, performance, reliability.7. Opportunities for warranty and post-warranty service, availability of a service network, availability and cost of parts.8. Real user reviews.
All power tillers can be conditionally divided into 3 groups by the producer country. The first model is from well-known manufacturers in Germany, the Netherlands and Korea. According to owners’ reviews, these units are of high quality, productivity, and reliability. The disadvantages are also clear. the high price and possible problems with maintenance, procurement of parts, etc.
Slightly inferior in quality and reliability of power tillers of domestic production, to which Belorussian machinery adjoins. Among the advantages are the price / quality ratio, the availability of inexpensive spare parts and components, unpretentiousness.
Chinese models stand out among the cheapest on the market. There are among them quite high-quality equipment, and noticeably inferior to the Russian samples in terms of reliability and durability. The main advantages are low and wide range of models.
Patriot Kaluga
Lightweight single axle tractor for small country houses. Weight 75 kg, pneumatic wheels, PTO, 2 front speeds, 1 rear. According to reviews, the unit is very easy to work with, especially for people with small size. Processes simple soils well.
Neva MB-2
This single axle tractor has been manufactured in various modifications for over 30 years. This legendary machine is notable for its high reliability, unpretentiousness, it is well adapted to our conditions. Thanks to the availability of spare parts the servicing of the power tiller will not be a problem. Several variants are available with different engines (including Subaru and Honda) and slight differences in functionality.
The manufacturer produces both small and medium-sized power tillers weighing from 70 to 105 kg. The heaviest in the line are diesel versions of the model MB-23 weighing up to 115 kg.
Weima WM1100A
Diesel single-axle tractor of Chinese make in weight of 115 kg. Productive, with reinforced pinion gearbox and reduction gearbox. The tractor has a wide range of functions, you can connect a variety of attachments (pump, snowplow). According to reviews, can carry in a trailer more than a ton of cargo.
Belarus 09H
The heavy-duty unit weighing 180 kg with a Japanese Honda 9-liter engine.с. and a 6-speed gearbox. Performs a wide range of agricultural operations, can control the operation of pumps, circular saw, feed chopper, etc. Among the advantages. the manufacturer’s developed service network.
The most popular models of Chinese Zubr motor blocks: it’s educational
Nowadays, when working in the field it is impossible to do without a good heavy power tiller. For maximum efficiency the machine must be perfectly suited to the worker, and he, in turn, must have the skills to operate such a machine. That is why it is extremely important to know what the best and most reliable power tillers are. Powerful heavy designs are needed when it is necessary to plow the ground containing salt marshes or tree roots.
Block: 1/5 | Number of characters: 443
Popular European models
Heavy power tillers are especially popular in Southeast Asia and the People’s Republic of China. It was there that the first models began to appear, the weight of which reached 300 kg. There they are used to work on the wet and clayey surface of rice fields.
In Europe it is a common practice among manufacturers to limit the weight of the construction to 100 kg. At the same time, it is still considered heavy and powerful. For example, the weight of the well-known model “Caiman 330” is slightly over 100 kg. At the same time it uses a diesel engine with a capacity of 9 liters. с. Such a unit can easily work on a plot of 100-200 acres.
By using Italian materials manufacturers have reached the highest level of reliability and efficiency. Today it is the most popular and high-quality model of a heavy power tiller.
The second most popular model is the “BCS 730” with a Honda engine, which has a capacity of about 10 horsepower. The weight of the construction can be up to 120 kg.
Almost all European models of heavy power tillers have the following characteristics:
- Weight of the construction is from 100 to 150 kg.
- Thanks to good alignment and balancing the single-axle tractor is very confident in any terrain.
- Japanese and American engines are used, the power of which varies from 9 to 12 liters. с. In most cases, gasoline engines are used, but you can also meet diesel versions.
- Achieving maximum operating comfort through gearboxes and gears on which the transmission is built.
Unlike Asian units, European models can hardly be called heavy. The fact is that in these areas it is easier to use a mini-tractor than to operate such a weighty structure.
Block: 3/5 | Number of characters: 1758
Main differences
Equipment for agricultural work must be chosen with great care and attention. Mechanical and electric land tillage units are expensive. Not every gardener is willing to lay out the money for a thing that turns out to be unnecessary. For the sake of this, it is worth knowing well what is the difference between a single-axle tractor and a cultivator.
Externally, both units are similar to each other. They are designed for pre-sowing and harvesting tillage. But they have big differences. The power tiller loosens the ground. This operation is necessary before planting the future crops. A single-axle tractor does the same work, but can also clear snow in winter, transport various loads, and split firewood. This is the main difference between a single-axle tractor and a power tiller.
The moth-cultivator can be made with a gasoline or electric motor. It presents many conveniences when cultivating small areas. The single-axle tractor can be equipped only with a gasoline or diesel engine. It moves on its own wheels with grousers. Among power tillers only high-powered units are capable of such cultivation. This is another difference, which is endowed with cultivators and power tillers.
The engine power of the power tiller is less than that of the power tiller. The capabilities of power tillers allow you to work hard ground on surfaces with the possibility of overturning other machines. The weight of the heavy implement gives it good traction. The cost of these machines is higher than that of cultivators. Worth buying for big plots of land. The main differences between the machines end here.
A single-axle tractor is a good helper for the farmer. It performs the main works, distinguished by the heaviness. These include:
- plowing the soil;
- cultivation;
- harrowing the area;
- plowing crops;
- furrow cutting;
- Crop cultivation;
- harvesting.
Cultivator can work on an area of 3-4 hectares. It helps to save your health. Now it is clear what is the difference between the machines.
Block: 2/6 | characters: 1920
Pros and cons of tillers and power tillers
The weight of the power tiller is about 100 kg (dimensions vary slightly from model to model). This machine has a wide wheelbase, a cooling system, a complex transmission, the option of fixing additional equipment. As equipping all of this equipment adds at least a dozen pounds, respectively, controlling motobloc more complicated. This option is the best for a large farmer who has a huge farm at his disposal, but not for a country house. Cultivator weight varies from 30 to 50 kg. That’s why it’s easier to operate such a device. This is best for the dacha owner, who has a small amount of land at his disposal, where the range of tasks is minimal.
Technical characteristics
Buying a cultivator or single axle tractor, you must pay attention to the technical characteristics. Among the number of such of particular importance are the following:
- Power;
- The depth and width of processing;
- Weight;
- Fuel consumption;
- Type of gearbox;
- The number of functions in the basic configuration of the unit.
Fuel tank capacity
At first glance, the more horsepower in the machine, the more efficient and high-quality work of the device. But that’s not quite right. After all, too high power motor leads to an increase in labor and fuel consumption. Nevertheless, if you approach this question from the perspective of certain tasks, the costs of production do not play a primary role. For example, in order to treat not more than five acres of the garden, it is best to buy a unit with an engine capacity in the range of three to five liters.с. This motor will not only be economical in terms of costs, but also lightweight. For more than five acres, but less than ten acres it’s better to work with a unit with power of 5-7 liters.с.
Working depth and working width: the optimal values
At first glance it might seem that it is better to buy a device with a larger working width, because in fact it will be able to work a larger area. At the same time, in this case you need to be cautious, because an increase in area often leads to a decrease in the load on a single knife, which will result in less effective work. And pushing a machine is much more difficult. Almost identical with working depth. The result is a heavier load, the engine suffers and wears out more quickly. Additionally, fuel consumption increases. Working widths between 60 and 90 cm are regarded as optimal. These specifications are common to many models. The more compact device will have a width of 30 to 60 cm. The optimum working depth varies between 20 and 35 cm. What would be the best option?? Consider the type of soil and the size of your garden. Because black earth and sandy soil need to be worked at cutting depths of 20 to 25 cm. Soils over 30 cm are heavy soils. A cultivator is not suitable here, only a single-axle tractor is appropriate.
The small weight of the unit will not often get stuck in the mud, respectively, to cope with it the farmer will be much easier. But, nevertheless, experts recommend to adhere to the optimum weight to power ratio. one to ten. unit weight with 2-3 liters. is approximately 25 kg, 6-7 l.с about 60-70 kg and so on.
Tank capacity
Such a figure affects how long you can work on one charge. The optimal variant. in the range of 3-5 liters, which provides at least a couple of hours of autonomous operation.
Block: 3/4 | Number of characters: 3464